The High Court in Nairobi has upheld a decision directing that a criminal case involving former Nairobi Provincial Commissioner Davis Nathan Chelogoi continue before Magistrate Dolphina Alego.
Justice Alexander Muteti dismissed Chelogoi’s challenge against the reassignment of the case.
High Court backs Magistrate Alego’s jurisdiction
The judge ruled that Alego retained her criminal jurisdiction as a magistrate despite her transfer to the Employment and Labour Relations Court.
Chelogoi, who is the first accused in the case, had argued that Alego no longer had authority to handle criminal matters after her transfer.
He also challenged the decision by Nairobi Chief Magistrate Lucas Onyina to return the case to Alego after it had initially been placed before Senior Principal Magistrate Rose Ndombi.
However, Justice Muteti found that Alego’s deployment did not cancel her status or jurisdiction as a magistrate.
Chelogoi challenges Sh1.3 billion land fraud case
Chelogoi and Andrew Aseri Kirungu are facing charges of conspiracy to defraud, forcible detainer and forgery.
By the time Alego was transferred, 19 prosecution witnesses had testified and 136 documentary exhibits had been presented in court.
The defence proceedings had also commenced.
Chelogoi had asked the High Court to quash proceedings conducted before Alego, arguing that her transfer affected her authority to continue handling the case.
Court allows case to return to Alego
Justice Muteti relied on Section 79 of the Criminal Procedure Code, which allows the transfer of cases between magistrates within the relevant jurisdiction.
The judge found that Chief Magistrate Onyina had the power to reassign the matter to Alego.
The court particularly considered that Alego had already heard the entire prosecution case before her transfer.
However, Justice Muteti faulted the Chief Magistrate for making the reassignment without first involving all the parties.
Despite this, the judge ruled that the omission did not invalidate the reassignment because Chelogoi had not demonstrated that he suffered prejudice.
Chelogoi may still seek Magistrate Alego’s recusal
The High Court declined to shut out Chelogoi’s application on procedural grounds.
Justice Muteti noted that the High Court has supervisory jurisdiction over subordinate courts and can intervene where procedural irregularities arise in criminal proceedings.
The judge directed that the Sh1.3 billion land fraud case continue before Magistrate Alego.
However, if Chelogoi still wants Alego to recuse herself, he can pursue the application before the trial magistrate before further proceedings take place.

